Amid abortion bans, Muslim Individuals flip again to their religion’s ruling on abortion : NPR



For the reason that Supreme Court docket eradicated the constitutional proper to an abortion, many Muslims Individuals have been turning to their religion to attempt to determine: What does Islam say about abortion?


For the reason that Supreme Court docket’s resolution to finish the constitutional proper to abortion final yr, some Muslims in America have turned to their religion to achieve a greater understanding on a key query – what precisely does Islam say about abortion? NPR’s Linah Mohammad reviews.

LINAH MOHAMMAD, BYLINE: Eman Abdelhadi had lots occurring in 2015. Professionally, she was learning sociology in grad faculty. Personally, she was originally of a critical relationship. She was switching contraception strategies when she acquired pregnant.

EMAN ABDELHADI: I did not have the assets to have a child at that second in my life. I wanted to complete my Ph.D. I used to be too quickly into this relationship. I did not have the cash on a grad scholar wage. And I merely did not wish to have a child.

MOHAMMAD: It was a tearful resolution, however Abdelhadi says her companion wasn’t prepared both.

ABDULHADI: Inside per week of discovering out that I used to be pregnant, I made a decision to get an abortion.

MOHAMMAD: Abdelhadi is now an assistant professor within the College of Chicago’s Division of Social Sciences. She research folks’s relationships with Muslim communities.

ABDULHADI: I’m very pleased with my life, and I do know that I would not have led the life that I lead now if I had made the choice to remain pregnant.

MOHAMMAD: And he or she says she’s safe in her option to get an abortion due to her upbringing in a religious Muslim group within the Midwest.

ABDULHADI: I discovered lots in regards to the Muslim custom within the sense that, you recognize, to begin with, the mom’s life is crucial factor.

MOHAMMAD: Polls present opinions on abortion, like in different religion teams, are deeply divided. In keeping with a survey carried out final March by the Institute for Social Coverage and Understanding, 56% of Muslim Individuals suppose abortion ought to truly be authorized in all or most circumstances. You may discover that quantity stunning for those who have a look at some non-Muslim perceptions of abortion in Islam. A easy Twitter search unveils tons of of feedback spinning the Supreme Court docket’s strikes to overturn Roe v. Wade because the Christian model of Shariah legislation. Here is former “Day by day Present” host Trevor Noah.


TREVOR NOAH: In any case these years of the correct screaming in regards to the threats of Shariah legislation, it seems they have been simply jealous. Now, to be clear…

MOHAMMAD: Critiques vary from makes an attempt at humor to downright Islamophobic takes. One meme that made the rounds on social media was a photoshopped picture of Supreme Court docket justices in beards, turbans and burqas. Consultants on Shariah legislation say these assumptions come from a spot of ignorance as a result of Islam can truly be very permissive of abortion.

ZAHRA AYUBI: A few of the most conservative – so-called most conservative international locations on this planet – like, for those who say, like Iran or Saudi Arabia – are extra permissive of abortion than many American states are.

MOHAMMAD: That is Zahra Ayubi, a professor of Islamic ethics at Dartmouth Faculty. She says key Islamic texts do not point out abortion outright, so rulings within the religion lean on verses that point out fetal growth.

AYUBI: Primarily based on the verses of the Quran and the Hadith and the prior discussions that jurists have had, we are able to say that 120 days is basically the purpose at which ensolement happens, the purpose at which we are able to contemplate the fetus a authorized individual. And so previous to that, abortion is permissible underneath sure circumstances.

MOHAMMAD: Ayubi additionally says the religion’s ruling on abortion depends upon which Madhhab or faculty of thought you select to comply with. Some are extra liberal, however it doesn’t matter what, there’s at all times an exception for the pregnant individual’s well-being in Islam.

AYUBI: Essentially the most conservative opinion is that abortion is permissible solely in circumstances of mortal hazard to the mom at any level.

MOHAMMAD: Ayubi additionally notes that a number of the conservatism over abortion is tied to outdoors influences.

AYUBI: Muslims have traditionally had abortions for the reason that starting of Islam. That being mentioned, Muslims have additionally had heavy affect from Christian discourses and have been traditionally colonized by varied European forces for a very long time. And lots of legal guidelines have been set as much as criminalize what have been very authorized actions that girls took with respect to being pregnant and abortion and so forth.

MOHAMMAD: And it is nonetheless troublesome to speak overtly about abortion in Muslim areas.

SHENAAZ JANMOHAMED: Hello, all people. We’ll be recording at the moment.

MOHAMMAD: And that is why HEART, a sexual well being group that serves Muslims, has been co-hosting digital workshops like this one…

JANMOHAMED: At occasions, the content material that we are going to be overlaying will probably be upsetting…

MOHAMMAD: …To supply sensible steerage and area for collective prayer.

ALIZA KAZMI: Ameen. That was so stunning. Thanks a lot…

MOHAMMAD: Sahar Pirzada is a supervisor at HEART and says prayer has been key in her personal reproductive choices. As she held her 3-month-old son on one other Zoom name, she instructed me about her first being pregnant in 2018.

SAHAR PIRZADA: We had gone to a number of ultrasound, had heard the heartbeat, had seen the fetus transferring.

MOHAMMAD: Pirzada and her husband had been overjoyed. However later checks confirmed the fetus had Trisomy 18, a uncommon genetic situation that nearly at all times ends in miscarriage or stillbirth.

PIRZADA: Nothing prepares you for that second whenever you get the precise prognosis. I did pray. I did make dua’a (ph). I did, you recognize, flip to God as I used to be making this resolution. And I felt extra at peace and ease than form of I believed I’d have.

MOHAMMAD: She talked it over together with her husband, her therapist and a number of Islamic students and determined to terminate the being pregnant.

PIRZADA: I believe it is simply in the end understanding that I – as an individual who’s carrying the fetus, I’m essential, too, proper? And my well-being is essential. And that actually comes from my understanding of Islam as effectively.

MOHAMMAD: An understanding that Pirzada says she’s grateful to share by way of her work. Linah Mohammad, NPR Information.

Copyright © 2023 NPR. All rights reserved. Go to our web site phrases of use and permissions pages at for additional info.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by an NPR contractor. This textual content is probably not in its remaining type and could also be up to date or revised sooner or later. Accuracy and availability could fluctuate. The authoritative file of NPR’s programming is the audio file.



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here